Private schools are typically organized in two different ways: as for-profit entities or not-for-profit (nonprofit) entities. For-profit schools are usually owned by corporations or private individuals who aim to make a profit without being eligible for tax-deductible contributions. On the other hand, not-for-profit schools choose to organize themselves under a nonprofit status, allowing them to make money while also receiving tax-deductible contributions.
Now, let’s examine the advantages and disadvantages of for-profit and not-for-profit schools. Is one type of school inherently better than the other?
For-Profit Schools
A for-profit school is typically owned and controlled by an individual or a group of individuals. This ownership model is commonly seen in pre-schools and some elementary schools. Another form of ownership is a corporation, often owned and operated by local individuals. Larger for-profit private schools are usually owned by corporations with multiple locations. These schools aim to make a profit and pay taxes on their earnings. Parents pay for the school’s services as customers. Examples of for-profit schools include Le Rosey in Switzerland, Sylvan Learning Centers, the Nobel Schools, and numerous small nursery and primary schools. They can be incorporated or have other ownership structures.
For-profit school owners have complete control over decision-making. While parental input may be considered, the final authority lies with the owner. If parents are dissatisfied, they can choose to enroll their children in a different school.
Not-for-Profit Schools
Most not-for-profit private schools seek 501(c)(3) status from the IRS after incorporating. This nonprofit status exempts the school from federal, state, and local taxes. It also allows the school to accept tax-deductible contributions. Nonprofit status is designed for entities that contribute to the greater good of the community, a category that schools typically fall into.
Obtaining tax-exempt status is important for schools because donors are more likely to contribute when their donations are tax-deductible. This is particularly true for major donors who may make significant gifts of $25,000 or more.
Some not-for-profit schools have a shareholder structure, where parents own shares in the corporation based on the number of children they have enrolled.
Most not-for-profit schools have an active board of trustees that governs the school. Depending on the school’s charter, the board of trustees has extensive powers. The school’s headmaster is typically hired by the board of trustees. This governance structure ensures the school can continue operating even after its founder is no longer involved, potentially lasting for generations. Examples of not-for-profit schools include Kent School and Exeter Academy.
Does the Legal Status of a School Matter?
No, one type of school is not inherently better than the other. The success of a school is determined by its teaching, achievements, and the satisfaction of its parents and students; not by its governance structure.
Furthermore, the legal structure of a school is not the primary concern when considering private education for your child. As long as the school is legally operating, that is the main point of consideration.
What truly matters are the basics: academics, athletics, and extracurricular activities. If these three areas meet your approval, you are almost there. Additionally, it is essential to ensure that the school is the best fit for your child.
You may also want to explore the following:
- Is the school adapting to current market conditions?
- Is it managing its finances efficiently and legally?
- Does the school have a strategic plan in place?
A private school that is unable to adapt to market conditions, manages its finances poorly, or lacks a strategic plan may face difficulties. To determine if these issues are present in a school, conduct thorough research and visit the schools in person. The answers to these questions will likely be evident.
In conclusion, the legal status of a school is not as significant as its management. A well-managed school, regardless of its profit status, is crucial for providing a quality education.
If you have any questions, feel free to contact us on Facebook @privateschoolreview.
